Valeria or Gina – who was on the third position?

In Phil MGain report from Calema Midwinters Festival on the third place in the Women Division is Valeria Matuck (BRA-704) but on the official results on this place we see Gina Rodrigues (DOM-28).

For explanation please look at the tables below (send us by Dorota’s father). Who is on the third position depends on the system used.

Probably the system used by the Race Committe was as described in the Sailing Instruction, but Phil has used for calculation the separate women fleet system (as in Euro-Cup events).

Official Women fleet results

1 POL1 Staszewska Dorota 23 *47 39 25 43 = 130
2 GBR95 Horwood Lucy 36 *79 34 42 40 = 152
3 DOM28 Rodriquez Gina 36 73 *98 71 14 = 194
4 USA41 Marriot Karen 36 *66 63 64 56 = 219
5 US2 Rosenberg Julie 36 65 *67 66 61 = 228
6 BRA704 Matuck Valeria *98 63 60 45 68 = 236
7 H1 Suits Chrissy 36 *76 71 67 71 = 245

Women fleet results as separate Division

1 POL1 Staszewska Dorota 1 1 2 1 *3 = 5
2 GBR95 Horwood Lucy *8 7 1 2 2 = 12
3 BRA704 Matuck Valeria *8 2 3 3 6 = 14
4 USA41 Marriot Karen *8 4 4 4 4 = 16
5 US2 Rosenberg Julie *8 3 5 5 5 = 18
6 DOM28 Rodriquez Gina *8 5 8 7 1= 21
7 H1 Suits Chrissy *8 6 6 6 7 = 25

* – discard